Forum

Jim Peter's Collapse in the 1954 Vancouver Empire Games marathon

Jackie Mekler, Dan Tunstall Pedoe, DPhil, FRCP

Abstract


On 7 August 1954 the world 42km marathon record holder, Jim Peters, collapsed repeatedly during the final 385 metres of the British Empire and Commonwealth Games marathon held in Vancouver, Canada. It has been assumed that Peters’s collapsed from heatstroke because he ran too fast and did not drink during the race held in windless, cloudless conditions with a dry bulb temperature of 28°C.

Review of his hospital records recently made available to the authors indicates that Peters may not have suffered from exertional heatstroke, which classically produces a rectal temperature of > 42°C, cerebral effects and a usually fatal outcome without vigorous active cooling. Thermal balance calculations also suggest that the environmental conditions were probably not sufficiently severe to induce heatstroke even at the high rate of energy expenditure sustained by Peters for 2 hours and 22 minutes.

Although Peters was unconscious on admission to hospital approximately 60 minutes after he was removed from the race, his rectal temperature was 39.4°C and he recovered fully even though he was managed conservatively and was not actively cooled.

We propose that Peters collapse was more likely due to the combination of hyperthermia-induced fatigue which caused him to stop running; the onset of exercise-associated postural hypotension as a result of a low peripheral vascular resistance immediately he stopped running; the combined cerebral effects of hyperthermia, hypertonic hypernatraemia associated with dehydration and perhaps an undiagnosed hypoglycaemia. But none of these conditions should have caused a prolonged period of unconsciousness, raising the possibility that Peters may have been suffering from a transient encephalopathy, the exact nature of which is not currently recognized.

Authors' affiliations

Jackie Mekler,

Dan Tunstall Pedoe, DPhil, FRCP,

Full Text

PDF (478KB)

Keywords

Heat stroke; marathon; exercise; collapse; fluids; sodium; creatine kinase; haemoglobin

Cite this article

South African Medical Journal 2008;98(8):596.

Article History

Date submitted: 2007-12-15
Date published: 2008-08-04

Article Views

Abstract views: 1976
Full text views: 1635

Comments on this article

*Read our policy for posting comments here